| Platinum | Gel's Kitchen 2 |
| Gold | Johnny's Chalet |
| Silver | Joeyo's |
| Bronze | Newport Creamery |
| Top Pick | Alice's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | English Muffin |
| Top Pick | My Favorite Muffin |
| Top Pick | Sunnyside Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sweet Dee's Cafe and Cupcakery |
| Top Pick | The Cozy Grill |