| Platinum | Sophia's Tuscan Grille |
| Gold | Fresco |
| Silver | Siena Cucina Enoteca |
| Bronze | Elizabeth of Portofino's |
| Top Pick | Basta Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Carrabba's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Chelo's Hometown Bar & Grille |
| Top Pick | Greenwood Inn Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rigatoni's |
| Top Pick | Sam's Inn |