| Platinum | Crow's Nest Fish House & Oyster Bar |
| Gold | Tommy's Clam Shack |
| Silver | Iggy's Boardwalk |
| Bronze | Elizabeth of Portofino's |
| Top Pick | 15 Point Road |
| Top Pick | Bluefire Grille |
| Top Pick | Finn's Harborside |
| Top Pick | Greenwich Bay Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Greenwood Inn Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Shanty |