| Platinum | Picasso's Pizza & Pub |
| Gold | Filippou's Twisted Pizza |
| Silver | Caserta's Pizza |
| Bronze | Pam's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Demitri's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dimitri's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | George's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Not Your Average Joe's |
| Top Pick | Pizza King |
| Top Pick | Rigatoni's |